Agenda - Columbia Borough Council Meeting - September 8, 2020

Download the 40-page council packet HERE.

Council renders decision on historic district property

24-26 South Second Street

Mayor Leo Lutz cast the deciding vote overriding a Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) recommendation concerning modern materials in the historic district. At issue was whether or not to allow an alteration to replace deteriorating balcony rails with composite material instead of the traditionally recommended wood. The vote could open the door for more of the same - to the detriment of the historic district and in opposition to HARB recommendations, which are based on U.S. Secretary of Interior Standards.

On Tuesday night, Columbia Borough Council voted 3-3 on the issue, and Lutz broke the tie in favor of allowing composite. Councilwoman Pam Williams abstained, because she is a tenant in the 6-unit apartment building, located at 24-26 South Second Street. The property is owned by Cimarron Investments, whose CEO is Don Murphy. The decision allows Murphy to use composite railings on four balconies.

Murphy first requested the alteration at the August HARB meeting, where members of the board voted 4-1 to deny the request. Murphy subsequently took the issue to borough council, which voted 3-3 on the request at last week's meeting. The vote was initially interpreted as a denial for HARB - and a win for Murphy - but council needed to take a second look at the issue this week because borough solicitor Evan Gabel said the tie vote actually meant council needed to vote again within 10 days.

At this week's meeting, councillors held fast to their original votes, leading to the same 3-3 tie, until Lutz cast his vote. Last week, Lutz abstained without explanation but was required to vote this week.

According to borough ordinance, the "address side" and any side of a building facing a main street in the historic district is reviewable by HARB. Murphy argued that the side of the building in question faces a secondary road (Avenue I) and is therefore not reviewable.

Council president Heather Zink, vice president Sharon Lintner, and councilman Howard Steven's voted to uphold the HARB decision, with councillors Todd Burgard, Fran FitzGerald, and Eric Kauffman voting against it. (Lintner, Burgard, and Fitzgerald live in the historic district.)

Dilapidated railings on the side 
facing Avenue I

During discussion leading up to the vote, Burgard suggested that due to the amount of investment Murphy has made in the borough, he should be given a free pass on the issue. Burgard also recommended that council take another look at the ordinance governing materials. "I would say let's give him his railing with the contingency of taking a look at the ordinance, see where, where modern building materials that save money, that look original, that allow for maintenance-free investments, and that might be cheaper," Burgard said. (Burgard has previously been affiliated with Murphy through his design business and his membership on the CHI board.)

Council vice president Lintner noted that residents who have appeared before HARB had to abide by its recommendations. "There was a gentleman at HARB one time had a small porch railing and it was a semi or row home and did not want to approve any of the material for him, so I'm just saying if, if we hold a resident living in a semi-detached house who's not making a profit off of their property accountable to HARB ordinance, how can we let someone else slide?" Lintner asked. Lintner also noted that the Second Street Street property sits near the Wright Ferry mansion which is one of Columbia's most historic properties. "So if you're letting that go in that block, we may as well not have a HARB."

Mayor Lutz argued from the standpoint of safety. He claimed that composite would be less costly, more durable, and safer. Like Burgard, Lutz recommended that council reexamine the ordinance to take into account materials available today. "One failure we have is keeping up on this ordinance with the times," Lutz said.

View from Bank Avenue

New policies for Glatfelter's Field include a limit of 250 people for home games

CBAA and The Glatfelter Foundation:

All-our CBAA football and cheerleading season is about to begin on Saturday, Sept 5th. As with everything else, COVID has changed how we do business. In the past, our home games were a true community event and the kids loved seeing all of the people there to support them. Unfortunately, those large gatherings are not possible at this time. Per the state guidelines, we are only allowed 250 people inside Glatfelters at any given time. As such, the CBAA and Glatfelter Foundation are implementing the following policies:

1) On days we have home games, we will only be allowing 250 people inside the park. In order to maintain this, parents that have kids participating in cheerleading and football will be given two (2) tickets for entry. We are only allowing two (2) spectators per participant. This is more than other organizations are allowing and many have cancelled cheerleading. This allows parents/families to see their kids participate.

2) If you do not have a ticket, you will not be allowed into the park during the games.

4) We have adjusted the start times of the games to earlier in the day as we think this will help with the number of people. Our home games will be scheduled for 11 am and 1 pm. If you do not have a child participating, we ask that you respect these times and avoid use of the park.

3) If there are any issues at the gate, it could cause the boys and girls seasons to be cut short and we do not want that to happen. They have worked hard to get to this point and need to be active and involved. Please do not do anything to take that away from them.

We are requesting that on the following days between 9:45 and 3 pm to avoid using the park. Any individual inside the park will count against the 250 people limit and may keep players and parents from entering.

CBAA has home games on the following days:

Sat. 9/5
Sat 9/26
Sat 10/10
Sat 10/17
Sat 10/31

While we love having everyone there, in this current environment it won't be possible. Please be respectful of the work the kids and coaches have put in so that they can have a positive experience and spend time with their friends, which they need during these challenging times.

CBSD School Board Committee Meeting - September 1, 2020

GO HERE TO VIEW: LINK

"Essential Oils Made Easy" Tuesdays at the Library via Zoom

Pennsylvania eviction moratorium set to expire as thousands face housing crisis

Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf confirmed that he will not extend the state's moratorium on evictions and foreclosures, set to expire Monday night, citing legal constraints that prevent him from acting without legislative approval.

MORE:

https://www.phillyvoice.com/pennsylvania-moratorium-evictions-foreclosures-expire-renters-mortgage/ 

Columbia Borough deeds recorded as of Aug. 31, 2020

Kevin A. Kauffman and Connie M. Kauffman conveyed 463 Walnut St. to Samuel B. Fisher and Emma K. Fisher for $165,000.

John M. Fleckenstein and Christina M. Fleckenstein conveyed property on Chestnut St. to Christina M. Fleckenstein for $1.

G&Z Investments LLC and David J. Garpstas conveyed 38 S. Eighth St. to Margaret T. Walters for $150,000.

James G. Farrington and Carol A. Farrington conveyed property on a public road to James G. Farrington, Carol A. Farrington and Kristin Noeleen Farrington for $1.

Scott D. Weibel conveyed 803 Locust St. to Gary A. Motter and Julia A. Motter for $185,000.

Kelly States conveyed 137 Bethel St. to Tracy L. Feulner for $110,000.

WGMC Properties LLC and Walter L. Siderio conveyed 569 Walnut St. to Gary A. Motter and Julia A. Motter for $99,900.

Redevelopment Authority County Lancaster conveyed property on Perry Street to Stonecrest Builders LLC for $18,000.

Edward M. Haas and Edward Haas conveyed 461 Locust St. to George Steedle for $96,000.
Nicholas Jason Sileo conveyed 707 Florence St. to Daniel A. Torres and Janene P. Winkey for $142,999.