Monday, May 11, 2026

Columbia, you must claim what is yours


Dearest Gentle Reader,
Your humble correspondent must take up her quill today to address a matter of some considerable civic importance — one that touches upon glory misappropriated, history insufficiently celebrated, and the peculiar habit of one's neighbors claiming credit for one's own most magnificent inheritance.

Let us speak plainly of Columbia — that storied borough upon the Susquehanna — and of two of the most extraordinary sons ever to grace its streets: Mr. William Whipper and Mr. Stephen Smith. These gentlemen, one a businessman and abolitionist of the first order, the other his equally formidable partner, operated a lumberyard in Columbia that was, in truth, something altogether more magnificent than mere commerce. Hidden within their train cars were secret compartments, and within those compartments rode human souls — men, women, and children — traveling from the darkness of bondage toward the blessed light of freedom. Dear Reader, one shudders with admiration.

And yet — and here is where your correspondent must fan herself with some vigor — it is Lancaster that has seen fit to celebrate this legacy, as Whipper and Smith are featured prominently in its exhibits. Lancaster now hosts a lecture series in Whipper's honor. Lancaster's public library welcomes his descendants to speak. Lancaster's institutions drape themselves in the rich fabric of a story that was, at its very heart, Columbia's story.

One does not begrudge Lancaster its enthusiasm — enthusiasm for history is always a virtue — but one cannot help but observe that Columbia itself has done precious little to claim what is rightfully hers. Where, pray tell, is Columbia's monument to these men? Where is the historical marker — other than a simple plaque — of suitable grandeur along the very streets where Whipper and Smith conducted their heroic enterprise? Where is the lecture series, the dedicated exhibition, the civic pride that ought to overflow like the Susquehanna herself in the spring thaw — especially now, in this celebration of Columbia's 300th year?

The family of William Whipper — represented most recently by the estimable Dyymond Whipper-Young of Philadelphia, an artist, educator, and storyteller of considerable accomplishment — travels not to Columbia to speak of her ancestor's deeds, but to Lancaster's public library. One feels the sting of this, or rather, one feels that Columbia ought to feel the sting of this, were she paying sufficient attention.

Mr. Whipper was born in Drumore Township, yes, but it was in Columbia that he built his life, his business, and his legend. It was in Columbia that the midnight work of liberation was carried out with extraordinary ingenuity and at considerable personal peril. Smith and Whipper did not merely assist the Underground Railroad — they engineered it, quite literally, concealing freedom within the very infrastructure of commerce.

Columbia, Dearest Reader, possesses a history that other municipalities would construct elaborate fictions to claim. And yet Lancaster constructs not fictions but actual institutions, while Columbia rests, apparently, upon her laurels — laurels she has not even fully cultivated.

Your correspondent urges — nay, implores — the good citizens of Columbia to remedy this oversight with all appropriate haste. Celebrate your Whipper. Celebrate your Smith. Hang their portraits, erect your markers, speak their names from rooftops facing that great river that carried so many toward freedom. Do not allow history to be relocated, like so much unclaimed luggage, to the next town down the highway.

Lancaster is a fine city. But this, Dear Columbia, is your story.

With the utmost affection and no small measure of exasperation,
Your Most Devoted Correspondent,
Lady Whistletown

Deeds Recorded — Columbia Borough — May 11, 2026


Ulrich Brent A, Ulrich Katelyn D, Ulrich S. Marlene conveyed property on Locust Street to Ulrich Brent A, Ulrich Katelyn D. for $1.

Lancaster Rentals LLC conveyed 460 Locust St. to Marlon Malpica for $275,000.

The estate of Martha M. Grab conveyed property on Locust Street to Farabaugh Property Group LLC for $177,025.

Gregory A. Nikolaus conveyed 691 Cherry St. to Zachary I. Nikolaus for $133,200.

Frank J. Doutrich conveyed 740 S. 12th St. to HNT Builders Inc. for $80,000.

Sunday, May 10, 2026

About Town — May 10, 2026

This week's photos of Columbia 
Click on photos to see larger, sharper images. 

JOE LINTNER | COLUMBIA SPY 

Details of the 1948 American LaFrance at Columbia Crossing on a rainy Saturday...













There it is, in all its glory.



*****************

Possible hawk's nest way up in a sycamore 

Someone dumped dirt at the former McGinness property.
Who and why?


*****************

The Creamline Cruiser is on its way to somewhere.

Teetering, about to fall in

Electric scooters 

*****************

On Monday, Elwood "Tim" Deeg was named Grand Marshal of the upcoming Lancaster County Firefighters Parade. 




*****************

Fine figure of a killdeer on Heritage Drive 

A work in progress 

The finished product 

Congratulations, Chief Jack Brommer 

Congratulations, Chief Holly Arndt 

The cakes were part of the celebration at the Columbia Fire Hall on Tuesday, May 5.

There's a used flag deposit box at the Legion. Dispose of your old, worn flag there. Don't wrap yourself in it like some politicians do.

Derailed rail

Hangin' at the tracks, heavily camouflaged

Missing street signs at 3rd & Cherry 

Norfolk Southern workers renovated the railroad crossing at the borough sheds this week. The supervisors are the ones standing around, doing nothing. 

New flag at Borough Hall 

Onward, children!

Workin' on the railroad 

When you just don't feel like stopping for that red light
[Submitted video]



Council narrowly approves police chief agreement; objections raised over contradictory language

Council voted 4-3 to approve an employment agreement for the borough's new police chief at its May 5 work session. 

JOE LINTNER | COLUMBIA SPY 

Columbia Borough Council voted 4-3 to approve an employment agreement for new police chief Holly Arndt during its May 5 work session, despite concerns about contradictions in the document.

Eric Kauffman, council president, said he, Borough Manager Jack Brommer, and Chief Arndt had reviewed the agreement together, and Kauffman described it as similar to the contract Brommer worked under when he was the borough's police chief. Arndt also requested that council support her in pursuing a master's degree in the future.  

Heather Zink, council vice president, said that although she believes Arndt is the right person for the job, she had reservations about the agreement sent to council members the night before the work session.

"It did not match what we had talked about in executive session," Zink said, noting that the borough's labor attorney said certain language he had included in the contract had been removed.

Zink also pointed out that council had previously agreed to remove civil service language from the agreement, but the version sent the night before still contained it. According to Zink, that language directly contradicted another provision in the document. Officials didn't state the specific language of the agreement due to confidentiality constraints. 

The issue boiled down to whether the chief would be an at-will employee, or be entitled to civil service protections. 

"I feel council is being strong-armed into voting for something," Zink said. "We want a contract that's going to stand up if there are challenges."
She also dismissed the argument that the agreement was acceptable because it was similar to Brommer's agreement. "That was 14 years ago and things change," she said.

Mayor Leo Lutz defended the agreement and called the labor attorney's comments largely advisory and "wishy-washy." "I don't see any reason to stall this and keep this chief on the hook," he said.

Council member Ethan Byers moved to table the matter, but the motion failed. Council then voted 4-3 to approve the agreement, despite the concerns over contradictory language. Zink, Byers, and council member Jeanne Cooper voted against the motion.

The action was unusual because council typically does not vote at a work session. Also, the late distribution of the agreement gave council members only a short time to review it.

Friday, May 8, 2026

Borough officials vow to shut down Makle Park if vandalism continues


JOE LINTNER | COLUMBIA SPY 

Borough officials, dismayed and frustrated by continued vandalism at Makle Park, said the park is close to being shut down. 

The most recent incident was an act of arson at the basketball court, in which a melted zipper was found fused to the court surface.

"It has to stop," Councilman Kelly Murphy said at the May 5 borough council workshop. He called on neighbors to remain vigilant and said this may be the community's last opportunity to save the park. "I think we really need to get the message out: This is your last chance. Take care of it, or you may lose it forever."

Mayor Leo Lutz echoed the sentiment: "If this continues, have a resolution and shut that park down." 

Resident Frank Doutrich said, "This has been going on for years, especially there, so we spend all the money, and we still don't have it solved."

Lutz outlined several measures under consideration, including new surveillance cameras aimed directly at the restroom doors and additional camera coverage across the park. He noted the borough has already spoken with residents of four newly built homes whose backyards face the park, asking them and others to keep watch. "So far, we haven't got a lot of help," Lutz said. He added that Police Chief Holly Arndt has recently increased patrols at the park. 

Future grant funding from the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (DCNR) may be at risk if the borough can't show proper upkeep  of the park. "DCNR is going to come down, they're going to look and say you can't keep up the money we spent. You're not getting any more," Lutz said. 

Lutz referenced a prior episode in which vandals broke a backboard and bent rims so badly that the borough removed them and effectively closed the courts. Resident Kurt Edmond Sr. later raised the funds to install new rims and backboards. Lutz said he hopes Edmond can again help remind the community to take better care of the park.

Borough Manager Jack Brommer noted that new lighting had recently been installed. Despite those improvements, Lutz acknowledged the park's somewhat secluded location makes oversight difficult. "It's the only park we have that is kind of out of public view," he said, adding that identifying suspects wearing hoods and masks presents a challenge.

Eric Kauffman, council president, said, "In any neighborhood, the more active they are, the less crime there is," he said. "If our parks are busy and occupied, then the trash won't build up, the bathrooms will be taken care of because people will want to use those parks."

Lutz noted that with warmer weather approaching, events are planned at the park — an opportunity to bring more eyes and community presence. 

Lutz said the borough would continue looking for community members to help monitor and maintain the park, and urged anyone with information about the April 28 arson to come forward. "The neighborhood needs to step up and take control of that area," he said. "Someone needs to speak up."

Thursday, May 7, 2026

Columbia Market House continues to operate at a loss; Borough officials acknowledge financial shortfall with no clear end in sight


JOE LINTNER | COLUMBIA SPY 

The Columbia Market House is still running in the red, borough officials acknowledged at the May 5 Columbia Borough Council workshop held at the Columbia Fire Hall. Council members warned that the deficit could persist for years to come.

Heather Zink, council vice president, confirmed that finance reports show the market is not breaking even. When resident Frank Doutrich asked, "Are we in the hole?" Zink replied: "Yes." The amount of the shortfall was not disclosed at the meeting, since the financial reports weren't on hand.

Doutrich said that since the borough currently lacks a finance manager, "Somebody should be on top of this." He also questioned whether the borough's accounting firm, Brown's, was monitoring the market's finances. Zink said the firm was not focused on that particular issue.

Zink, who reviews the market's finances as part of council's finance committee, suggested the market will remain in the red for the foreseeable future. She added that the financial situation could persist for a long time unless the market increases the number of renters, or stand rents are raised.

Doutrich noted that standholders appear to be turning a profit, and questioned whether borough taxpayers should at least be breaking even on the investment.

Columbia Spy previously reported on the Market House's troubled finances HERE.

The Columbia Market House, built in 1869, operated as a market until 1996, when it closed amid concerns about costs and a dwindling number of vendors. It reopened in 2005 but closed again just before Christmas in December 2017, according to lancasteronline. The building at 15 S. Third St. closed in December 2017 to undergo a several million construction and renovation paid for with a combination of state and local funds.

The borough-owned facility reopened after renovations in May 2021 under CHI St. Joseph Children's Health management. Ten months after reopening, the market saw several vendors leave and was welcoming shoppers only one day a week. CHI eventually stepped away from its management role, and the borough took over operations.



Truist Bank to depart, leaving Columbia without a bank; Officials consider moving borough accounts to Fulton Bank


JOE LINTNER | COLUMBIA SPY 

At the May 5 Columbia Borough Council workshop, officials discussed Truist Bank’s upcoming departure from Columbia Borough scheduled for July 28, 2026, which will leave the borough without a bank. A council member noted that it's the third bank to leave town over the past 10 years.

Eric Kauffman, council president, said he was unsure of how to go about getting another bank in town and whose responsibility it is to do so. “I don’t know how you get another bank in Columbia,” Kauffman said. “I don’t know if that’s the borough’s responsibility, if it’s merchants’ responsibility, to try and get a bank in Columbia.”

According to Kauffman, the bank building can't be sold to another bank due to stipulations of sale.

Kauffman said that when the borough was searching for a loan a few months ago, one of the banks they dealt with was Fulton Bank. “We were very pleased with Fulton Bank,” Kauffman said. “Fulton Bank not only wanted to give us a favorable loan, but they also wanted our services.” He recommended moving the borough's accounts to Fulton, noting that the issue will most likely be on next meeting's agenda. Fulton has a branch located right off Route 30 at the Mountville exit, Kauffman said.

After Truist leaves Columbia, the only convenient options remaining for borough residents (besides online banking) will be the Wells Fargo ATM at the Columbia Plaza, and Northwest Bank on 18th Street, which is in West Hempfield Township. 

Truist Bank, located at 325 Locust Street, has technically operated under its current name in Columbia Borough since its formation in December 2019, following the merger of BB&T and SunTrust, according to public records.